Eye On Regulation

 

Can an individual’s experience of racism be mitigating of unprofessional conduct? In McKenzie v. College of Nurses of Ontario, 2026 ONSC 5070, the Court considered an appeal from penalty imposed by a Panel of the Discipline Committee of the College of Nurses of Ontario that engaged this question.

Ms. McKenzie admitted to several acts of professional misconduct, including sleeping while on shift, failing to provide timely care to a patient, deficient documentation respecting other patients, and failing to follow the facility’s Code Blue Policy when attending another patient. The Panel ordered that Ms. McKenzie receive a reprimand, a one-month suspension, that she attend a minimum of two meetings with a regulatory expert, and that she notify her employers of the discipline decision for a period of 12 months after returning to nursing practice.

Ms. McKenzie appealed the sanctions imposed, asserting that the Panel erred in failing to adequately consider the anti-Black racism she experienced in her workplace and by declining to treat that racism as a mitigating factor.

A core issue at penalty hearing was whether Ms. McKenzie’s experiences of anti-Black racism in the workplace mitigated the admitted misconduct. Ms. McKenzie testified and filed documents relating to her experience. The College did not call any additional evidence on penalty and did not dispute that Ms. McKenzie had experienced racism and discrimination.

Relying onR. v Morris, 2021 ONCA 680, the Panel stated that Ms. McKenzie was not required to show a causal connection, but “some connection” was required between the overt or systemic racism and the circumstances or events said to explain or mitigate the conduct. It concluded this connection had not been established on the evidence.

The Court recognized that Ms. McKenzie’s testimony as to her experience needed to be approached with appropriate sensitivity, though it stated that mitigation is not the automatic result of experiences of racism. The assessment of any mitigation needed to be individualized and evidence based.

The Court found that the Panel recognized Ms. Mckenzie’s evidence concerning racism, and that it did not reject that evidence or dispute that racism can be mitigating in appropriate circumstances. The Court further found that the Panel identified the correct legal test in recognizing that only “some connection” needed to be established between the racism experienced and the circumstances or events said to explain or mitigate the misconduct. The appeal concerned the application of that test to the evidence presented.

While acknowledging that the Panel’s reasons could have been more extensive, the Court found that the Panel’s reasons, read with the record as a whole, showed that the Panel accepted Ms. McKenzie’s experiences of racism but was not persuaded that the evidence established the necessary connection between those experiences and the conduct at issue for it to be a mitigating factor for the specific professional misconduct admitted.

Concluding that no reviewable error had been demonstrated, the Court dismissed the appeal.


our two cents for free

R. v Morris, 2021 ONCA 680 and its approach to racism as a mitigating factor has been applied in Alberta both by courts in criminal matters (see e.g. R v Pierre, 2023 ABCA 300 at para 6) and in professional disciplinary proceedings (see e.g. see Mema (Re), 2026 ABCPA 6 at paras 554-558), indicating that evidence of an individual’s experiences of racism can be mitigating in appropriate circumstances.

What the courts have repeatedly stated across these cases is that an individual’s experience of racism alone is not sufficient to be considered a mitigating factor. Rather, there must be evidence establishing some connection between an individual’s experience of racism and circumstances alleged to mitigate the proven unprofessional conduct. Assessing evidence of an individual’s experience of racism requires sensitivity and care, and a tribunal’s engagement with that evidence in its reasons should show that it considered the evidence before it in light of the appropriate legal test, and explain its conclusions in a manner that is intelligible, reasoned, and responsive.

question

How can your tribunal ensure that it engages with sensitive subjects with appropriate sensitivity and provide reasons that demonstrate that approach?


Eye on Regulation is RMRF’s monthly newsletter for the professional regulatory community. Each month we offer:

  • A Case: a brief summary of a recent and relevant case;
  • Our Two Cents for Free: practical insight inspired by the files on our desks right now; and
  • A Question: something to get you thinking about ways to enhance your work.

This newsletter is for information only and does not constitute legal advice.


Would you like to receive this Newsletter directly to your inbox each month?

Sign up here


 

subscribe to
our mailing list

subscribe

get the latest updates via RSS

RSS link What is RSS?